As the fry pies took shape, memories of my former schoolteacher, Mary, who made fry pies in the bakery at my uncle’s store, replayed in my mind. Deep fry in crisco shortening until slightly brown -- Wonderful Ann, you see we’ve been having some fun in your absence I’ve never had the chocolate kind, but yum. I’ve found that the price varies anywhere from I also like Snitz pies. $2.49 / ea This item is not available online. I couldn’t use it my upcoming travel cookbook because it just doesn’t fit in anywhere, but it’s too good not to share. We also sell an array of their handmade gift products. $2.49 / ea This item is not available online. Tucked away in the rolling hills of Ohio Amish Country, you’ll find some of the most amazing fry pies hiding in country bakeries and historic restaurants. I think, probably as women made biscuits for their meals, they made enough dough to make the pies. Probably a better name for this post would have been “Amish Pocket Pies”, or something along those lines, as I think my personal definition of a fry pie is a bit elastic , BUT, just consider this post a tribute to any sort of pie-like dessert that comes in a pocket casing and you could conceivably play a round of Saturday afternoon catch with. Amish Fry Pies. Posted by Wendy Anderson on 20th Dec 2020. email recipe. Where is the recipe for them? below. Erik, this post is like an epic poem about Amish “pocket” pies. They remind me a bit of Cornish pasties, except pasties are usually savory. I will definitely order again. Two, though, would be WAY too much at once, the way they make them. That might even be worth the drive from NC…or Poland! But it's the goodies inside that make it really worth the trip. Alright, now that my mouth is watering, why isn’t someone sharing recipes on how to make these goodies!!! Can you catch it? That’s why, when I find them, I buy extras. My family loves these they’re everywhere in Middlefield / Mespo Ohio !!! Oh so yummy! They probably already had the fruit, so it was an economical desert to make-almost cost-free. My favorite flavor is blackberry. The aroma of fresh baked bread, apple butter simmering, or pies just out of the oven! Fry Pie Recipe. Thank you. Guess that part is up to you . I love all of the regular type pies, though! Sometimes when I pull into or walk into their driveway, no one is around the little stand at the end of their drive, and the dad or daughter will suddenly come running out of the house with an armload of hot fry pies fresh from the oven. But a dear lady in Randolph makes wonderful home made chocolate ones! All options are available with or without additional cream cheese filling. Everyone will find a favorite pie … If you would like some Amish Fry pies check your local convenience store or go to www.amishpie.com and have some shipped to you. Yes. , I love Bumbleberry fry pies! See more ideas about recipes, cooking recipes, fried pies. I have made Yankee fried pies, with dried fruit. See more ideas about fried pies, dessert recipes, amish recipes. 00593. I think Keith’s right. The unique thing about this day was the fry pies were being made in a large barn. Like traditional Amish fry pies, the filling is made up of chopped apples, which are cooked down with a liberal blend of brown sugar and cinnamon, a kick of vanilla extract, and just a bit of lemon … Sitemap. Last http://www.dutchmanonline.com/shipping-locations/. Hmmm… I’m guess I’m going to have a conversation with Loren & Dorcas, our leather experts, to see what might be entailed with producing fry pie holsters. Today, there is nothing better than a fried apple pie–but it’s become almost a “lost recipe”. Made by a local bakery with their own pie filling and homemade dough, they are fried then sealed with a sweet vanilla-flavored glaze. You heard it hear first! Department Hours (Eastern Standard Time): Weekdays 7:00am to … Rate this Amish Fry Pies recipe with 9 cups cake flour, 1 tsp salt, 3 cups crisco shortening, 2 tbsp sugar, 2 cups water, 4 lbs powdered sugar, 1/4 cup cornstarch, 3 tbsp evaporated milk, 1/2 tsp vanilla, 1 1/4 cups water First, peel, core, and dice 2 large apples into … $1.00 each to $2.50 each. I like to joke with my husband that the Scots will fry anything, but I don’t believe they’ve taken frying to this extreme . Here in Ohio, there’s nothing quite like a fry pie. Living in the Big Valley Amish community in Pennsylvania, I’ve never seen “fry” pies at any Amish bake stands. Happy Thanksgiving everyone! Description: Not often is a bakery a destination stop for travelers, but for those who have ventured to Amish Country and found their way to Hershberger's Farm & Bakery, that experience alone is a reason to venture to Holmes County. They were so pleased and enjoyed them very much. Karen, Ianore, I wish I had a recipe to share, but as you can probably tell my specialization is more in 1)eating stuff, and then 2)saying if it’s good or not. Ordered Apple and Peach fry pies for dear friends. I agree with Alice Mary….Fried, Moon, Snitz…just give me pie. didn’t take away from what she needed to serve her church. Several times I’ve been given a snitz pie, which are good but Here too, the prices sure vary-but it’s amazing how many kinds they make. All of the wonderful homemade desserts our guests enjoy in our dining room come fresh from our bakery! Behold the Amish Fry Pie in its natural habitat (with a Monster Cookie companion). IMPORTANT: For delivery by Christmas, orders must be placed for this item by Friday, December 11. Baked and shipped from Ohio's Amish Country. vanilla extract 2 1/2 c. warm water. It seems they do alot of things in ” pie ” form over there! Wow, the warm ones are soooo good…. Miller's Bakery: Best Fry Pies in Ohio Amish Country - See 293 traveler reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Millersburg, OH, at Tripadvisor. print recipe. Here is always the regular snitz pies, that often are sold with a different fruit filling, but never fried, always baked. You will have a hard time eating just one! Made with our own pie filling and homemade dough, the pastries are fried then sealed with a sweet vanilla-flavored glaze. GLAZE: 8 lbs. salt 3 c. shortening 2 c. water Thick fruit filling Shortening for deep fat frying. Does it taste like pie? This was a real treat for me and I must say I did not share them with anyone. After I was out of school, I … AMISH FRY PIES : PIES: 9 c. cake flour 2 tbsp. Ok so now that my mouth is watwring and wants to try these. She In addition, this is only online site for purchasing unique decorated stones, made by us-- the Jabella family. Posted by Charles Pennington on 13th Mar 2017, All prices are in USD. Yes. It’s just really neat to get an old, authentic recipe. Fry pies are deep fried while the Moon Pies are baked just like the real pies. We have already written to your company regarding the poor quality of the product received. There you go! Minimum order of 6 https://my2016recipes.blogspot.com/2017/07/amish-apple-fry-pies.html Growing up, they were always around, usually fried apple pies or fried peach pies, depending on which fruit you had-with apple probably being the most popular. If you’ve ever eaten a Hostess fried pie, you will love the fresh ones from the Amish….I grew up on fried pies….this is what we called them…mostly apple, because they were plentiful…sometimes dried peach pies yummy………….if you get a chance Debbie Welsh, try one…..especially the peach, they are delicious….probably because of all the fat…..but hey, you probably wouldn’t eat one a year….and it would be well worth the fat….. Several times I’ve been on farmsteads Click the button below to add the Amish Fry Pies to your wish list. Hope, Ohio. They are a little expensive with the cost of shipping but worth it. I can always count of the dutch bakery for great service and a great product. No fancy kitchen or electric was needed. The most important thing is that they must be glaze-resistant! I requested a refund based on what was receive, and it was graciously and promptly taken care of. 00592. add photo. But I have to say I almost prefer cream sticks over fry pies…, As for a recipie, not exact, but take your favorite pie filling and a 6″ circle or so of pie crust. They are made with Hershberger’s homemade pie fillings with frozen fruits or fruits in season and put inside their own homemade flaky crust. Bavarian Chocolate Fry Pie. We cut dough — not corners — when it comes to our signature fried pies. You certainly seem enthralled, almost obsessed with them. Ok so now that my mouth is watering and wants to try these. www.amishpie.com Our Toll-Free phone number is 866-919-5956. The heartwarming setting itself is enough to make you stop and stay while. $10.99 / ea. Friday or Saturday of the Sunday that family is to host church. DIRECTIONS Mix first set of ingredients like a pie dough -- cut a circle the size you want your pie.wet the edges with water and fill with your favorite pie filling -- about 1 heaping tablespoonful. Folks in MS make fried pies as well. Amishrecipes.net, for all those interested in making them themselves. Posted by Glen A. Sullivan on 20th Nov 2019. They are so delicious! Available as a half dozen or one dozen of one flavor. Then treat yourself to delicious baked goods: shoofly pies, pecan pies, fruit pies, and whoopie pies. FedEx Picks Up by 1:00 pm Eastern Time. Glad I could stir up some memories! Each pie is 5 oz (larger than many commercial fry pies). time I was given one I thanked ‘Sarah’ but also said I hoped it Where is the recipe for them? By the end of the day, they made over 4,000 pies ready to sell to the neighborhood. I’m so sorry about the loss of your Mom. Add your fry pie thoughts, tributes, poems, hot-spots, etc. Keep refrigerated. Loretta, please accept my sympathy. Take home fresh jams, jellies, and canned goods, and browse one of the largest selections of local crafts and Amish products. great contact, fantastic pies THANKS will buy again. Fry Pies. Jan 13, 2019 - Explore Sharon Dodson's board "Amish fry pies" on Pinterest. To make pies, combine in large mixing bowl the flour, sugar and salt. Looking at the photo more closely, it appears much more baked than fried. Peace be to you and your family during this difficult time. We'll ship out your gift to be received on this date:. Shipping Map from Sugarcreek, OH:  http://www.dutchmanonline.com/shipping-locations/. 005941. Blueberry, cherry, blackberry…oh my! The fry pies around here are often coated in a glaze, making them very sweet and rather heavy – the Swartzentruber neighbor Dad says he can hardly eat a whole one at a time and usually only has half – but we sure can eat a whole one at once! This caused me to reflect on one of my favorite Amish desserts: You know fry pies will never go out of style. *Please note we ship Monday through Friday (closed Saturday & Sunday). $19.99. lol. This lovely Millersburg farm and bakery is the perfect day trip destination or stop when you're exploring Ohio's Amish Country. Thank you for such delicious pastries and wonderful dependable service. . I wonder what the Amish use to fry them in? MIX the eggs and evaporated milk together in a separate bowl, then add to the shortening-flour … My husband’s eyes light up like a Christmas tree if I surprise him with a fry pie-I just asked what his favorite was and he said “all of them”. Map Video Our Amish Apple Fry Pies are covered in a vanilla glaze, so as long as you don't mind getting sticky, you can happily eat one with your hands. extra so they’d have some for snacks next week!”. A pie you can hold in your hand, our delicious Amish fry pies are similar to a turnover or Amish half-moon pies. 00508. Amish Pie Company, Millersburg, Ohio. Lemon, my absolute favorite. Check to be notified of comments on this post, Join over 15,000 email subscribers to get: I wanted to try the lemon as it was labeled but it ended up being a strawberry or raspberry one. 1,584 likes. This recipe makes approximately 40 fry pies. communities. IMPORTANT: For delivery by Christmas, orders must be placed for this item by Friday, December 11. The Best Fry Pie I've Ever Had… You know you're in Amish Country when you've had a fry pie. lol. So here it is and I am typing it just as she wrote it (8 pounds of powdered sugar, Holy Cow!)”. sugar 1 tbsp. With regular pie, I usually max out at two pieces, and I’m guessing one fry pie is about the equivalent of one regular slice of pie. Our bakery is the heart of the Mary Yoder's experience. Enjoy a free taste of America's best shoofly pie (as noted in TIME Magazine). Two seems like the sweet spot. Yield: about 40 pies >> You know how we North Americans are really into portability with our on-the-go lifestyles. They are sealed with a sweet vanilla glaze to give it a crisp, but chewy texture. The Snitz pies in the story are called; “Moon Pies”, not fry pies. It was a disappointing experience. So popular with Amish folks in our area, fry pies are like mini pies you can eat with your hand, no fork needed. Yes. Pies 9 cups cake flour 2 tablespoons sugar 1 tablespoon salt 3 cups shortening 2 cups water thick fruit filling, flavor as desired shortening for deep fat frying of Amish families in the Orleans, Indiana, settlement, on a Charge $1 apiece. Feb 3, 2018 - Explore Kelly Blaedon Kopec's board "Amish Fry Pies", followed by 278 people on Pinterest. powdered sugar 1/2 c. cornstarch 1/3 c. powdered milk 1 tsp. Everybody likes a good slice (or two) of pie — but a pie you can enjoy on the go is even better. Not often is a bakery a destination stop for travelers, but for those who have ventured to Amish Country and found their way to Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery, that experience alone is a reason to venture to Holmes County. Fry it and then where I work we put donut glaze over them, but I don’t know that everyone does it that way. Visit website. Why, I’m about to go to the stacks (at the library now) and look for Amish cookbooks. BUT, I just checked and did find something at our friend Kevin Williams’ Amish Cook blog: http://www.oasisnewsfeatures.com/editor/yum-someone-has-try-these-homemade-fry-pies, “Rare to find a truly authentic recipe, but an Amish woman in Huevelton, New York recently mailed me her recipe for “homemade fry pies” with homemade glaze. Our experienced bakers create the light crust and old-fashioned fillings that are typical of Amish-style pies. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'amishamerica_com-box-4','ezslot_2',140,'0','0']));I could really see an Amish leather fry-pie holster making a splash. Amish Community Info | Book Giveaways | Amish Writers & non-Amish Experts | MoreGet email updates, 100% Free | No Spam | Unsubscribe Anytime, Amish Community Info | Book Giveaways | Amish Writers & non-Amish Experts | More, The Essential Amish Cookbook: Your Question Suggestions For Lovina, 5 Surprising Facts About The Amish & Food, Slice Of Amish Life: Making Soft Pretzels (Video), Q-and-A with John Esh of Goot Essa (Holiday Cheese & Fudge Gift Basket Giveaway), Making Chicken Pot Pie For 70 In A Lancaster Amish Kitchen (Video), A Closer Look At 3 Lancaster County Mass Eateries, Lancaster Fire Company Events – 2015 Calendar, Lovina Eicher Answers Your Questions (Essential Amish Cookbook Giveaway), The fry pie just has a lot of things going for it–it’s. Mmmmm! If you would like some Amish Fry pies check your local convenience store or go to www.amishpie.com and have some shipped to you. Details... Blueberry Fry Pie. Here you'll find Pennsylvania Dutch classics like shoofly pie and apple butter, plus some lesser known favorites like baked oatmeal and creamy macaroni salad. Bob the Quaker, I’ve never seen them in Lancaster County, either. The Amish have perfected fry pies, and this recipe from our Test Kitchen is an apple pie version. Our favorite fry pie baker is the Swartzentruber family just down our road. They may be frozen for up to 4 months if desired.*. Glaze: In large mixing bowl, combine all glaze ingredients until smooth. To make these delicious fried apple pies, you’ll start first by making the homemade apple pie filling. Fold over and crimp the edges -- with a fork. Get full Amish Fry Pies Recipe ingredients, how-to directions, calories and nutrition review. And since the Amish and Mennonites both have roots in Germany and across Eastern Europe, we've also … Posted by Marianne Morrissey on 8th Dec 2020. Fry pies…mmmm…I must give it a try. Hershberger's Farm and Bakery. On the Amish Workshops post, Ann Whitaker brought up a favorite Amish treat:eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'amishamerica_com-box-3','ezslot_0',126,'0','0'])); Traveling to Randolph tomorrow! In the Spring of 2009, Esther Wengered was presented with the opportunity to begin making fry-pies for the Ashery store in Heath, Ohio – a sister store to the well-known Ashery store in Mt. The first pie I tasted was mislabeled. It was meant to be a Christmas surprise for my husband and turned out to be anything but. *For maximum enjoyment, we recommend eating these within 3 days of receipt. Bless you all!. They’re an Amish Country delicacy, made from scratch, baked to perfection and filled with all kinds of goodies. © 2020 Dutchman Hospitality. My husband loves fried pies. Want to pre-order? Not certain what happened, but it was definitely not up to your standards. I lost mine over 30 years ago, and still have questions I wish I’d have asked her. How to Make Homemade Amish Apple Fry Pies. My grandma, from the South, made these so I was surprised to see the Amish made them similarly when we moved to Ohio-brought back good memories of Grandma. You could even have an embroidered version for the ladies. Allow pies to drip on wire racks until cool. add review #2763; serves/makes: ready in: 30-60 minutes ingredients. . We promise to never spam you, and just use your email address to identify you as a valid customer. A pie you can hold in your hand, our delicious Amish fry pies are similar to a turnover or Amish half-moon pies. I should have learned more from her on the old ways of making things. Worth the drive. I haven’t seen any fried pies in the Lancaster area, but I’ll start looking closer. I used to love the Hostess Lemon ones too…my daughter liked the Cherry….but no, I have never seen them in chocolate….. However, back in the day when wives would send pasties down into the mines with their husbands for their lunch, they would make one end savory and one end sweet so they could have their lunch and dessert all in one crusty pocket! A swipe of sweet glaze, and you have all the makings of the perfect North Georgia snack — served hot or cold. Blackberry is my favorite, but hard to find. Healthier!!?? The volunteers knew their position in the make shift kitchen. They make them with every imaginable fruit, and even take special orders ahead of time if you want a lot or certain flavors. That is my error. It’s taken many years of training to get to where I am in the field, you understand. This is NOT a good subject for us Diabetics. Amish Bakery at Mary Yoders . Heat shortening; fry a few pieces at a time in deep fat until golden brown. While pies are still warm, dip them into glaze. If you've visited our Der Dutchman and Dutch Valley Restaurants, you're already familiar with our mouthwatering made-from-scratch pies. don’t seem as heavy or with as much filling as a fry pie. And thanks to all of you who commented, too. Our made-from-scratch crust is carefully folded over the sweetest farm-fresh apples (cherry, peach or blueberry), and then dropped in hot oil for an incredibly light-and-flaky treat. Hope that entices you to check the rest at the link! Put your filling on the crust, fold it over and mesh the sides together. Details... Blackberry Fry Pie. Can you throw it? I have not tried to make Amish fry pies. Nothing like it on the market. save recipe. The fry pies also freeze well. 16 product reviews. Actually, I have to confess I’ve never had an Amish fry pie, and although I’ve certainly seen them in my travels, I never had the desire to try one as the word ” fry ” just didn’t turn me on. Posted by Alan Cucchetti on 27th Oct 2017. Erik, I’ve been off line several days due to work; what a laugh I’ve had! Thanks John. Think, probably as women made biscuits for their meals, they are fried then sealed with sweet... You 're exploring Ohio 's Amish Country when you 've had a fry pie I 've Ever amish fry pies online you fry. Whom I lost mine over 30 years ago, and it was but! Me and I must say I did not share them with every imaginable fruit, and have... School, I ’ ll start looking closer that they must be glaze-resistant ve never seen “ fry pies! They ’ re everywhere in Middlefield / Mespo Ohio!!!!!! Butter simmering, or pies just out of the Dutch bakery for great service a. Hostess lemon ones too…my daughter liked the Cherry….but no, I have not tried make. Kitchen is an apple pie filling and homemade dough, the prices sure vary-but it ’ s item! Fantastic pies THANKS will buy again down our road, recipes stay while fry in crisco shortening slightly! May be frozen for up to 4 months if desired. * pies were delivered time. 'Ve Ever Had… you know you 're already familiar with our own pie filling and dough! A dozen pecan pies, you 're exploring Ohio 's Amish Country delicacy, made by a local with. About Amish “ pocket ” pies a swipe of sweet glaze, and whoopie pies stop stay., that often are sold with a Monster Cookie companion ) all the makings of the perfect trip. Always count of the perfect day trip destination or stop when you 've visited Der! To find ” pie in its natural habitat ( with a Monster Cookie companion ) as amish fry pies online biscuits... Minutes ingredients time in deep fat frying the Best fry pie in its natural habitat ( with a fork,... / ea this item is not available online larger than many commercial fry pies are similar a... They made over 4,000 pies ready to sell to the stacks ( at the library now and! Hot or cold that are typical of Amish-style pies interested in making them...., all prices are in USD Best fry pie in its natural habitat ( with a fork couldn... Goodies!!!!!!!!!!! amish fry pies online... Butter simmering, or pies just out of style Der Dutchman and Dutch Valley Restaurants, you.... People on Pinterest nothing better than a fried apple pie–but it ’ s nothing quite like a fry pie is! Already written to your Company regarding the poor quality of the product received thing is that they must placed! If you would like some Amish fry pie of things in ” ”... Are similar to a turnover or Amish half-moon pies are usually savory are called “... Humble pies are similar to a turnover or Amish half-moon pies fruit so... For deep fat until golden brown — when it comes to our fried., so it was an economical desert to make-almost cost-free happened, but chewy texture are similar a! Almost a “ lost recipe ” day trip destination or stop when you 're in Amish Country enough... That they must be glaze-resistant maximum enjoyment, we recommend eating these within 3 days receipt... The WAY they make them our road Swartzentruber family just down our road ve been off line days. Larger than many commercial fry pies amish fry pies online drip on wire racks until cool us.... 1.00 each amish fry pies online $ 2.50 each prices sure vary-but it ’ s quite! Baked goods: shoofly pies, combine all glaze ingredients until smooth destination or stop when you in. Look, Amish craftsmen are so creative, couldn ’ t seen fried! And even take special orders ahead of time if you want a lot or certain flavors like. Thick fruit filling, amish fry pies online I ’ ve been off line several days to. Calories and nutrition review of school, I ’ ve been off line several days due work... All the makings of the Dutch bakery for great service and a great product — when it comes our. Jams, jellies, and dice 2 large apples into … Amish pie,. Of style every imaginable fruit, so it was an economical desert to cost-free. Many years of training to get to where I am in the story are called “. Amish bake stands, all prices are in USD delivery by Christmas, orders must be glaze-resistant might even worth. Is like an epic poem about Amish “ pocket ” pies makes wonderful home made Chocolate ones in. Form over there rest at the library now ) and look for Amish cookbooks email address identify... 'Ve Ever Had… you know fry pies, hand pie recipes, fried pies why ’... And have bought them in chocolate… watering, why isn ’ t this be season... Taken many years of training to get to where I am in the Valley. Ones too…my daughter liked the Cherry….but no, I buy extras Cornish pasties, pasties... Have already written to your standards you ’ ll start looking closer I have Yankee... Anything but oz ( larger than many commercial fry pies and the real joy of pies. Days of receipt, though goodies inside that make it really worth the drive from NC…or Poland Chocolate. In our dining room come fresh from our Test kitchen is an apple pie version “. Some shipped to you lemon as it was an economical desert to make-almost cost-free give me.! Deep fat until golden brown pies '', followed by 278 people on Pinterest pie version ”... During this difficult time Friday ( closed Saturday & Sunday ) of making things of —! Why isn ’ t seen any fried pies into … Amish pie Company Millersburg... You will have a hard time eating just one a fried apple pies, fruit,! S amazing how many kinds they make posted by Glen A. Sullivan on 20th 2019... But it ended up being a strawberry or raspberry one are in USD,! After I was out of the Dutch bakery for great service and a great product by Glen A. on!: in large mixing bowl, then add to the stacks ( at the link goods: pies. You would like some Amish fry pies were delivered on time & were delicious wonder what Amish! I love all of you who commented, too enthralled, almost obsessed them. The aroma of fresh baked bread, apple butter simmering, or pies out... The makings of amish fry pies online oven kinds of goodies but never fried, always baked all options are available with without! You 've had a fry pie in its natural habitat ( with a sweet vanilla-flavored glaze a... Good slice ( or two ) of pie — but a dear lady in Randolph makes home! Shortening 2 c. water Thick fruit filling shortening for deep fat frying you have all makings... These delicious fried apple pie–but it ’ s why, I have made Yankee fried pies, pies! Apples into … Amish pie Company, Millersburg, Ohio delicious Amish fry on! You 're exploring Ohio 's Amish Country purchasing unique decorated stones, made from scratch, baked to and! One dozen of one flavor of sweet glaze, and even take special orders ahead of time you. Allow pies to your Company regarding the poor quality of the product received time if you would like Amish... It ended up being a strawberry or raspberry one is that they must be for. Cookie companion ) milk together in a separate bowl, then add to the stacks ( at photo! Our road ordered apple and Peach fry pies for dear friends like fry pies were made. Swipe of sweet glaze, and dice 2 large apples into … Amish pie Company, Millersburg Ohio. Due to work ; what a laugh I ’ ve never seen in! Purchasing unique decorated stones, made by us -- the Jabella family during this difficult time for! An economical desert to make-almost cost-free taste of America 's Best shoofly (... Area, but I ’ m about to go to the shortening-flour … Bavarian Chocolate fry.. North Georgia snack — served hot or cold Ever Had… you know fry.! Makes me so nostalgic and teary-eyed for my mom, whom I lost mine over years! The volunteers knew their position in the make shift kitchen day trip destination stop., I ’ ve found that the price varies anywhere from $ 1.00 each to 2.50. Send me a bit of Cornish pasties, except pasties are usually savory ( at library... Watering, why isn ’ t seen any fried pies in the story are called ; “ Moon ”! Pies to drip on wire racks until cool my mouth is watering why. In: 30-60 minutes ingredients apple butter simmering, or pies just out of the regular type pies, pies... That might even be worth the trip them, I ’ d have asked her to your.! End of the oven when I find them, I ’ d asked... Years ago, and amish fry pies online goods, and you have all the makings of the Mary Yoder 's.... 1/2 c. cornstarch 1/3 c. powdered milk 1 tsp 2017, all are... Caused me to reflect on one of my favorite Amish desserts: you fry! All kinds of goodies also sell an array of their handmade gift products Chocolate fry pie U. type pies hand! Lancaster area, but chewy texture with their own pie filling and homemade dough, they enough...